IEC 61851-23: DC charging stations
The safety and performance requirements for a DC charger: how its output is isolated and monitored, when it may put voltage on the cable, how precisely it follows the car's request and how it shuts down. CableCheck, PreCharge and WeldingDetection exist because of this standard.
Scope and system configurations
IEC 61851-23 is read together with IEC 61851-1: part 1 gives the general requirements and part 23 adds or replaces clauses for off-board DC chargers. The main text is common to all DC systems. Annexes describe the system specific parts for the three DC charging systems that existed when the first edition was written.
| System | Better known as | Coupler (IEC 62196-3) | Digital communication (IEC 61851-24) |
|---|---|---|---|
| System A | CHAdeMO | Configuration AA | Annex A, CAN |
| System B | GB/T | Configuration BB | Annex B, CAN |
| System C | Combined Charging System (CCS) | Configurations EE and FF | Annex C, powerline with DIN SPEC 70121 or ISO 15118 |
- Isolated versus non-isolated output: nearly all public DC chargers galvanically separate the DC output from the grid, which makes the output an IT system (not earthed) whose insulation has to be monitored.
- Regulation: the stations of all three systems regulate current to the car's request (called controlled current charging); a voltage regulated mode also exists in the standard.
- The station decides when to energise its output based on the pilot state or the equivalent signals of system A and B, the locking of the connector and the digital communication.
The terms controlled current charging (CCC) and controlled voltage charging (CVC) and the annex letters are from the 2014 edition. Check the second edition for renamed or added annexes.
Isolation monitoring and why CableCheck exists
Because the DC output floats, a single insulation fault does not trip anything: it just makes the next fault dangerous. The standard therefore asks for an insulation monitoring device (IMD, to IEC 61557-8) on the output during charging and for an insulation test of the cable and connector before energy flows. The test happens with the car's contactors still open, so it covers the charger output, the cable and the coupler up to the car's inlet.
| System | Where the test shows in a capture |
|---|---|
| CCS, DIN SPEC 70121 and ISO 15118-2 | CableCheckReq repeats while the response says EVSEProcessing Ongoing. DC_EVSEStatus carries EVSEIsolationStatus (Invalid, Valid, Warning, Fault, No_IMD) and EVSEStatusCode EVSE_IsolationMonitoringActive while the test runs. |
| CCS, ISO 15118-20 | DC_CableCheckReq repeats while EVSEProcessing is Ongoing; the charger ends with Finished and an OK response code, or a FAILED code. |
| CHAdeMO | The charger runs the test after locking the connector; a failure shows as a fault flag in 0x109 and the session stops before current flows. |
| GB/T 27930 | The insulation test runs in the handshake phase between CHM/BHM and CRM, so a long gap there is often the test itself. |
- The test voltage is chosen from the car's maximum voltage and the charger's rating, so the insulation is stressed at least to the voltage of the coming session.
- In CCS the car switches the pilot to state C before the cable check, because the charger may only energise the DC output with the car in state C or D.
- Some system annexes let the charger check for a short circuit between DC+ and DC- at low voltage before the insulation test.
- A Warning isolation status lets the session continue; Fault ends it. See the isolation code dictionary for each value.
Commonly quoted thresholds are above 500 ohm per volt for a valid result and at or below 100 ohm per volt for a fault, with a warning band between. Verify these, and the rule for the test voltage, against the clause and annex of the edition you test to.
Precharge
A battery sitting behind open contactors and a cable at a different voltage would see a large inrush current when the contactors close, which welds contacts and stresses capacitors. So before the car closes its contactors the charger raises its output to the battery voltage the car announces, with the current limited to a small value. In CCS this is PreChargeReq (DIN, ISO 15118-2) or DC_PreChargeReq (ISO 15118-20): the car sends its target voltage, the charger reports EVSEPresentVoltage, and the car closes its contactors once the difference is small enough, then sends PowerDelivery Start.
- A precharge that never converges usually shows EVSEPresentVoltage stuck or oscillating while PreChargeReq repeats until the car gives up.
- CHAdeMO and GB/T have the same step in their CAN sequences: the charger matches the battery voltage before the vehicle closes its relays.
- DIN SPEC 70121 limits the precharge current to a few amperes; the value to use is in its DC requirements.
The precharge current limit (often quoted as 2 A) and the voltage difference at which the car closes its contactors are not given here as tool limits. Verify them against DIN SPEC 70121 and ISO 15118-2 before using them as pass criteria.
Regulation accuracy, ripple and shutdown
The standard sets how closely the output current and voltage must follow the car's request, how fast the station must react to a new request, how much ripple the output may carry, and how fast current and voltage must fall when charging stops normally or in an emergency. In a capture this shows as the difference between EVTargetCurrent and EVSEPresentCurrent in CurrentDemand (or DC_ChargeLoop), or between the current request in 0x102 and the present current in 0x109 for CHAdeMO, BCL and CCS for GB/T.
| Requirement area | Charger side view | What the tool looks at |
|---|---|---|
| Current control | Output current within a tolerance of the request, for currents below and above a knee point | IS20-03 and IS20-04 for the limits, CH-02 and GB-05 for current at or below the request |
| Voltage control | Output voltage within a tolerance in voltage regulated mode and below the car's maximum | CH-03 and GB-06 for the voltage window |
| Ripple | Peak to peak ripple current and voltage below a limit over a frequency range | Not visible in protocol messages; needs a scope on the DC lines |
| Normal shutdown | Current reduced to a low value within a set time after a stop request | PW-03 on metered current, the stop sequence in SQ-01 |
| Emergency shutdown | Output switched off quickly on an internal fault, loss of communication, isolation fault or the emergency stop button | EVSEStatusCode EVSE_EmergencyShutdown or EVSE_Malfunction in DC_EVSEStatus; fault flags in 0x109; CST reason in GB/T |
The numeric tolerances, response times, ripple limits and the voltage the output must fall below after shutdown (60 V is often quoted as the touch safe level) are deliberately not repeated here. They differ between the 2014 and later editions and between system annexes; verify them in the standard.
Welding detection and the end of a session
A contactor that welds shut leaves battery voltage on the inlet after the plug is pulled. After the energy transfer the car opens its contactors and the charger reports the voltage it measures on the DC lines. In CCS the car sends WeldingDetectionReq (DC_WeldingDetectionReq in ISO 15118-20) and watches EVSEPresentVoltage fall; if it stays at battery level a contactor is welded. The loop ends when the car is satisfied, then SessionStop follows. CHAdeMO announces in 0x108 whether the charger supports welding detection, and the charger unlocks only after the voltage has dropped.
- EV: PowerDeliveryReq, ChargeProgress Stop; charger ramps current down
- EVSE: PowerDeliveryRes, charger output off
- EV: WeldingDetectionReq, car opens its contactors, repeats while the voltage falls
- EVSE: WeldingDetectionRes, EVSEPresentVoltage on the cable
- EV: SessionStopReq
Editions
- First edition, 2014: the edition most field chargers were certified to, with the system annexes for CHAdeMO, GB/T and CCS.
- Second edition: revises the general requirements, the system annexes and the test methods, and takes later developments such as higher power and bidirectional operation into account.
- Related newer documents extend the DC family, for example for automated connection devices and for megawatt charging.
The second edition is dated 2023 in most references, and the part numbers of the related documents (such as IEC 61851-23-1 for automated connection and IEC TS 61851-23-3 for MCS) should be confirmed before citing them.
Sources
- IEC 61851-23:2014, general requirements for DC stations and Annexes AA, BB and CC for systems A, B and C
- IEC 61851-23:2023, second edition, see the verify notes
- IEC 61557-8, insulation monitoring devices for IT systems