Billing and measurement testing
Why a charger that bills by energy is a legal measuring instrument, how the EU, Germany and the Netherlands handle AC and DC meters and signed readings, the US code in NIST Handbook 44 with NTEP and California type evaluation, the Canadian dispensations, and what a lab looks at.
Why a charger is a measuring instrument
When a customer pays per kilowatt hour, the energy figure on the bill is a measurement in trade. Legal metrology then applies: the meter has an approved type, the path from meter to bill is protected, and the customer can check the figure. The meter itself, OCMF and signed readings are described in Energy metering and signed meter values; this page is about the testing side.
A meter in a charger is not automatically a legal one. The Pionix Yeti power board, for example, is sold with an integrated meter marked as not MID, which is fine for development and not for billing.
EU and Germany
- The Measuring Instruments Directive (2014/32/EU, annex MI-003) covers active electrical energy meters, so an AC charger can use a MID approved meter. DC meters are not covered by MID, and national rules apply.
- In Germany the calibration law (MessEG and MessEV, called Eichrecht) treats the whole charge point as the measuring system: meter, display, the software that handles readings and the way they reach the bill.
- Readings are signed inside a protected unit, the public key is shown on the charger, and the customer checks the signed start and end values with transparency software published by S.A.F.E. e.V. The common container for a signed reading is OCMF.
Directive (EU) 2026/706, adopted on 11 March 2026 and published in the Official Journal on 20 March 2026, amends the MID for measuring systems of electric vehicle supply equipment. It adds a new Annex Va with harmonised essential requirements for these measuring systems, so the whole measuring system of a charger, AC or DC, comes under EU legal metrology and not only the meter inside it. Member states transpose it by 10 April 2028 and apply it from 10 October 2028, as the explanatory memorandum laid before the Northern Ireland Assembly sets out.
In the Netherlands, NMi, a Dutch notified body, describes the Metrologiewet as the Dutch implementation of the MID and notes that the MID as it stood covered AC meters but not the meters of DC fast chargers. NMi names prEN 50732, on measuring energy and time in stationary AC and DC supply equipment, as the planned harmonised standard under the MID, and OIML G 22 as the international guidance for EV charging equipment.
Not confirmed for this page: the accuracy classes and test points of Annex Va of Directive 2026/706, and whether France has national rules for charger metrology beyond the MID. Read the directive and the French legal metrology texts directly.
North America
- NIST Handbook 44, section 3.40, is the code for electric vehicle fueling systems. It entered the handbook as a tentative code in 2015 and became permanent from 1 January 2023; states adopt the handbook into their own law.
- Section 3.40 sets, for AC EVSE, an acceptance tolerance of 1.0 % and a maintenance tolerance of 2.0 %, and asks for accuracy tests at a current between 4 and 10 A and at one between 40 and 60 % of the maximum deliverable current, among other points. DC systems put in service before 1 January 2025 and marked accuracy class 5 have a tolerance of 5 % of the energy delivered.
- NTEP, the National Type Evaluation Program, evaluates EVSE types; section 3.40 refers to the NTEP Certificate of Conformance, for example for the temperature range an EVSE may be installed in.
- California: the Division of Measurement Standards (CDFA DMS) runs the California Type Evaluation Program (CTEP). An EVSE used commercially needs type approval and is inspected, tested and sealed by weights and measures officials. DMS issued its first type approval for commercial charging equipment in March 2021. DMS is also an authorised NTEP laboratory, and an NTEP certificate may be accepted in place of CTEP if the device meets all California rules. AC chargers installed before 1 January 2021 come under CTEP by 1 January 2031.
- Canada: Measurement Canada runs temporary dispensation programmes that let owners of chargers already in use bill by energy in kWh. For commercial Level 1 and Level 2 devices, the dispensation covers devices in service before 1 January 2028 and runs until 31 December 2029 (amended on 16 September 2025). For Level 3 and above (DC), it covers devices in service before 1 July 2024, and devices put in service from 1 July 2024 to 31 December 2029 under set criteria. The owner chooses whether to bill by time, by a flat fee or by energy under a dispensation.
What a lab looks at
- The meter type: an approval for the meter (MID for AC in the EU) and, where the rules require it, for the charger as a measuring system.
- Accuracy at the point of transfer: for DC the reading is corrected for the loss in the cable between meter and car, so the lab checks the correction against a reference measurement at the connector.
- Signed data: that each legally relevant reading is signed, that the signature verifies with the public key shown on the charger, and that the readings reach the backend and the bill unchanged.
- Display and records: what the customer sees during and after the session, and that it matches the signed values.
- Software: that legally relevant software is separated and protected against change.
This list follows the German approach described in Energy metering and signed meter values; the US tolerances and test points are those of Handbook 44 section 3.40 above. The European accuracy classes and the procedure for DC meters (IEC 62053-41 and national rules) were not checked for this page.
Meter values in the data
- To the car: ISO 15118-2 carries optional
MeterInfoinChargingStatusResandCurrentDemandRes; ISO 15118-20 answersMeterInfoRequestedwithMeterInfo. DIN 70121 carries none in the DC loop. - To the backend: OCPP 2.0.1 carries a signed reading as
signedMeterDataof aSignedMeterValue; with OCPP 1.6 this is vendor specific. - Most chargers do not send the signature to the car. The legal check is the one the customer makes with transparency software, not one the car makes.
In this tool
- PW-04 reports a meter reading that goes backwards within a session.
- The Curve tool takes energy from the meter when the session has two readings, and otherwise from the delivered power.
- The OCPP tab lists each transaction with its metered energy, which can be set beside the energy seen on the cable. The analyzer does not verify signatures and does not judge legal metrology.
Sources
- Directive 2014/32/EU (MID), Annex MI-003, as summarised in the Energy metering article
- German Mess- und Eichgesetz (MessEG) and Mess- und Eichverordnung (MessEV), as summarised in the Energy metering article
- Open Charge Metering Format (OCMF), S.A.F.E. e.V.
- ISO 15118-2:2014 and ISO 15118-20:2022, MeterInfo
- OCPP 2.0.1, SignedMeterValueType
- Pionix: BelayBox assembly kit, Yeti power board, non MID meter
- Directive (EU) 2026/706, amending Directive 2014/32/EU, measuring systems for EV supply equipment, OJ L of 20 March 2026
- EFTA: factsheet 32026L0706
- Northern Ireland Assembly: explanatory memorandum on Directive (EU) 2026/706, transposition by 10 April 2028, application from 10 October 2028
- ES France: Métrologie des bornes de recharge, la directive MID évolue, trade blog on the MID amendment
- NMi: testing and validation for EV charging stations
- NMi: EV charging systems, legal metrological infrastructure, white paper, 2023
- NIST Handbook 44-2026, section 3.40 Electric Vehicle Fueling Systems
- NIST OWM: Electric vehicle fueling FAQs, history of the code
- CDFA: California issues first type approval for commercial electric charging equipment, March 2021
- CALeVIP: Guide to California regulations for EV charging stations
- ChargeLab: What is CTEP?, AC chargers installed before 2021
- Measurement Canada: electric vehicle charging stations
- Measurement Canada: temporary dispensation for Level 1 and Level 2 EVSE
- Measurement Canada: temporary dispensation for Level 3+ EVSE
- SPEC.md of this tool, FR-TOOL-02 (Curve), FR-TOOL-06 (OCPP), PW-04