Fault injection on the Control Pilot and Proximity Pilot
The faults a charger test injects on the pilot and proximity circuits (diode missing or shorted, pilot shorted to earth, pilot open, earth open, proximity open), what IEC 61851-1 asks the charger to do, and what each looks like on an oscilloscope.
Why and how
A charger must stay safe when the car, the cable or the plug is faulty. Type tests prove this by breaking the pilot circuit on purpose, one fault at a time, and watching how the charger reacts. The Control Pilot itself is explained in IEC 61851-1: the Control Pilot.
Faults are injected with an EV simulator or a test adapter that has switches for each fault, not by cutting a cable. IEC 61851-1 Figure A.8 shows an example simulator; commercial ones are listed in Test equipment for charging.
These tests run next to mains or high DC voltage. They belong in a lab with the right protective measures and qualified staff.
The circuit in one paragraph
The charger drives plus and minus 12 V through a resistor onto the pilot wire. In the car, a diode is followed by resistors to earth; they pull the positive half down to the level of state B or C, while the diode keeps the negative half at about -12 V. The charger reads the state from the positive plateau and the presence of the diode from the negative one (IEC 61851-1, A.2.2 and Tables A.2 to A.4). The pilot returns through the protective conductor, so the pilot also proves that earth is connected (6.3.1.2).
The faults
| Fault | What the charger must do | Where in IEC 61851-1 | On the scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diode missing | Not close its contactor: diode presence is checked at least once before the supply is switched on | Table A.4 and the text after it; 6.3.1.3 | The positive plateau looks normal. The negative plateau is no longer about -12 V: the car resistors load it as well. From nominal values it sits near -9 V in state B and near -6 V in state C |
| Diode shorted | The same as a missing diode | As above | The same as a missing diode: a shorted diode conducts in both directions |
| Pilot shorted to earth | Treat it as state E: open the supply within the time the standard gives, then unlock the socket outlet | 6.3.1.2; Table A.5 (state E); Table A.6 (any state to E or F); test in A.4.9 | Both plateaus collapse towards 0 V and the PWM disappears. A.4.9 uses a low resistance rather than a dead short, so a small residual square wave may remain |
| Pilot open | Loss of continuity: switch the supply off within the time given for an open pilot circuit | 6.3.1.2 | The level jumps to +12 V (state A); if the charger keeps its PWM running, a full plus and minus 12 V square wave |
| Protective conductor open | Cut the power within the time A.4.8 gives, starting from state C or D | 6.3.1.2; A.4.8 | Like an open pilot: the pilot has lost its return path |
| Proximity open (Type 2 socket outlet, case B) | Treat the cable as absent or faulty and not energise; interrupt the supply if the coded cable current would be exceeded | Annex B, B.2 and Table B.2 | Nothing on the pilot. The proximity measurement reads a resistance above the highest coding range, which Table B.2 treats as an error or an unplugged cable |
| Charger fault | Signal it with state F, and after that follow the rules for state F (remain in F, or change to state x1 after a minimum time) | Table A.5 (state F) | A steady -12 V |
The negative plateau values for a missing diode are calculated here from the nominal resistor values of Tables A.2 and A.3, not taken from the standard; real values depend on tolerances and on the simulator. The response times are in the clauses named; read them there.
States E and F
- State E (0 V) usually means an error the charger did not choose: no power to the charger, or a pilot shorted to earth. The charger must not use it to signal, apart from the wake up workaround in A.5.3.
- State F (steady -12 V) is set by the charger on purpose to report a fault, for example that it needs maintenance. Without a fault, a charger that will not deliver energy signals this with state x1, not with F.
- Both states lead to the supply being switched off and the socket outlet being unlocked (Table A.5 and Table A.6).
- The optional hysteresis tests in A.4.11 move the pilot slowly between C and E, and D and E, to show that the charger does not flicker between states.
What to record
- A Control Pilot log or scope trace with a sample rate high enough to see each PWM period, from before the fault until the contactor opens.
- The time from the fault to the contactor opening, measured on the output voltage, not only on the pilot.
- What the charger tells its backend: the status and error code it sends over OCPP, compared with the codes ChargeX expects in its MREC list (The ChargeX EV-EVSE Interoperability Test Plan).
- Whether and how the charger recovers once the fault is removed.
This analyzer reads Control Pilot logs and runs the CP- checks on them, for example CP-02 on the plateau voltages and CP-09 on state F during energy transfer. The PF- checks name the fault the levels point to: PF-01 a missing diode (the negative plateau mirrors the positive one), PF-02 a pilot that opens to state A while energy flows, PF-03 a pilot held at 0 V (state E) beyond a retry step or during charging, and PF-04 a proximity pin that reads open while a car is connected. Control Pilot problems explains what the levels mean, and AC test cases, worked has worked AC cases that include a pilot short and a charger fault.
Sources
- IEC 61851-1:2017, 6.3.1.2, 6.3.1.3, Annex A (A.2.2, Tables A.2 to A.6, A.4.8, A.4.9, A.4.11), Annex B (B.2, Table B.2)
- SAE J1772, the North American coupler: the same pilot circuit and diode check
- ChargeX Consortium: ev-charge-seq-state, Argonne National Laboratory, Apache-2.0; PlantUML sequence diagrams and state machines of SAE J1772, ISO 15118-2 and ISO 15118-20 with OCPP 1.6J, 2.0.1 and 2.1
- INL: Minimum Required Error Codes by ChargeX