Smart charging: schedules, limits and grid signals
How a charging session is shaped in time: OCPP charging profiles from the backend, ISO 15118 schedules on the cable, the Control Pilot duty cycle on AC, grid signals through OpenADR, IEEE 2030.5 and EEBus, the UK default off peak hours, the German controllable device rules and utility programs, and why cars that pause do not always come back.
Three layers of control
| Layer | Who talks | How a limit is expressed |
|---|---|---|
| Grid to backend or site | Network operator, utility or aggregator to the charge point operator or energy manager | Price or load signals: OpenADR, IEEE 2030.5, EEBus, a control box, a tariff |
| Backend to charger | CSMS to charger, OCPP | Charging profiles: a limit in A or W over time, per station or per transaction |
| Charger to car | Control Pilot; DIN SPEC 70121, ISO 15118-2 or ISO 15118-20 | AC: the PWM duty cycle. ISO 15118: a power schedule (SAScheduleTuple with PMaxSchedule), or in ISO 15118-20 dynamic targets set by the charger |
A limit set at the top reaches the car only if every layer passes it on. When a car charges at the wrong time, the question is at which layer the limit got lost.
OCPP charging profiles
- OCPP 2.0.1 profile purposes:
ChargingStationMaxProfile(the whole station),TxDefaultProfile(every new transaction),TxProfile(one transaction) andChargingStationExternalConstraints(a limit from outside the CSMS, reported to it). - Within a purpose the highest stack level wins; between purposes the lowest limit in force applies, so a TxProfile cannot lift a station cap.
- The charger combines the profiles into a limit per connector and passes it down: as a duty cycle on AC, as maximum values or a schedule in ISO 15118, as the limits it sends a CHAdeMO or GB/T car.
- In ISO 15118 the car may also send its own charging needs; OCPP 2.0.1 forwards them with NotifyEVChargingNeeds and the resulting schedule with NotifyEVChargingSchedule. OCPP 2.0.1 and ISO 15118: the backend behind the cable explains how the two protocols meet in the charger.
Schedules on the cable
- ISO 15118-2 and DIN SPEC 70121: the charger sends up to a few
SAScheduleTupleentries in ChargeParameterDiscoveryRes, each aPMaxScheduleover time and an optional sales tariff; the car picks one by itsSAScheduleTupleIDin PowerDeliveryReq. To change it, the charger setsEVSENotificationtoReNegotiationand the car goes back to ChargeParameterDiscovery. - ISO 15118-20: in scheduled control the car picks a schedule as before; in dynamic control the charger sends targets during the loop and the car follows within its limits and mobility needs. The control mode stays fixed for the session (ISO 15118-20: control modes, BPT and power profiles).
- Control Pilot only: the duty cycle is the only lever. A pause is a duty cycle outside the charging range (IEC 61851-1: the Control Pilot lists the values), and the car has a few seconds to follow each change.
Grid programs and rules
| Region | Rule or program | Content |
|---|---|---|
| Great Britain (United Kingdom: smart charge points, the Public Charge Point Regulations and Type 2 with CCS2) | Smart Charge Points Regulations 2021 | Private charge points come with default charging hours outside 8:00 to 11:00 and 16:00 to 22:00 on weekdays, and start with a random delay of up to 10 minutes so that many chargers do not switch on at once when a cheap tariff begins; they must be able to take part in demand side response. The government is preparing a load control licence for companies that control such appliances (applications from 2026, in force from 2027, SSES programme). |
| Germany (Europe: AFIR, Type 2, CCS2 and ISO 15118) | Section 14a EnWG | Since 1 January 2024, new private charge points above 4.2 kW are controllable: the network operator may reduce them when the grid is at risk, but never below 4.2 kW. |
| United States (North America: J1772, CCS1, J3400 and the NEVI standards) | ENERGY STAR connected criteria; utility managed charging | Connected chargers support demand response through an open protocol: OCPP, SEP 2.0 (IEEE 2030.5), CTA-2045A or OpenADR 2.0. Utility programs such as the NV Energy managed charging program pay drivers whose home charging is at least 80 percent off peak, measured by the charger or the car. |
EEBus is the protocol family (SHIP transport, SPINE data model) that many European wallboxes, heat pumps and energy managers use to agree on limits inside the building.
Under section 14a, German network operators describe the control path as a control box (the FNN Steuerbox) behind the smart meter gateway: the box receives the command of the network operator through the gateway and passes it on to the wallbox or the energy management system over EEBus.
The OpenADR and IEEE 2030.5 profiles that specific utilities require, and whether a given German network operator also accepts other interfaces than the control box, are not described here; check the current rules of the network operator.
Cars that pause and do not return
- A study in Nature Communications (Brinkel, van Wijk, van Sark and others, June 2024) found paused and delayed charging problems in around one third of the car models tested: the car goes to sleep during a pause and does not resume. The authors estimate that removing these problems would double the smart charging potential.
- The Smart Charging Requirements of ElaadNL and the Dutch national charging agenda ask that charging can resume after a pause of any length, and advise keeping cars at their minimum current instead of pausing them. Their intermittent test switches the signal 25 times between 0 and 6 A at 60 second intervals.
- In the ElaadNL test program published on 30 September 2025 (142 vehicles, 10 charge points, 11 months), ElaadNL reports that a majority of the vehicles passed and that cars and chargers behaved as expected in normal smart charging.
When a smart charging product lets a car sit at 0 A for a long time, test each supported car for resume after 1, 10 and 60 minutes before relying on it.
What to record and test
- The OCPP log with every SetChargingProfile, ClearChargingProfile and the reports of the charger, the network capture of the same session, and the Control Pilot log with currents on AC.
- Tests: a profile sent before and during a transaction, two profiles with different stack levels, a station cap lowered below the running transactions, a renegotiation started by the charger, a pause and resume, and a backend that goes offline while a profile is active. Backend, Plug and Charge and payment test cases and AC test cases, worked have the forms.
In this tool
- The ac-ok demo has a Control Pilot log, a capture and an OCPP log of one AC session; the iso20 demo an ISO 15118-20 DC session in scheduled control.
- SQ-08 checks that the car uses a schedule tuple the charger sent; SQ-09 that it reacts to
ReNegotiationorStopChargingin time; IS20-02 that the control mode stays the same; IS20-09 that an ISO 15118-20 schedule renegotiation runs to PowerDelivery Start; CP-03 that each duty cycle is an allowed value; PW-01 that the current stays within the permitted limit, schedule included, afterpw.settlingTimeS. - The Power tab shows the permitted current and the measured current together, so a car that ignores a lower limit is visible at once. The Curve tool shows target against delivered current for DC.
- OCPP profile frames appear on the OCPP lane and in the table; the tool does not evaluate OCPP profiles itself.
Sources
- OCPP 2.0.1: ChargingProfilePurposeEnumType, ChargingStationExternalConstraints, ChargingStationMaxProfile, TxDefaultProfile, TxProfile
- Solidstudio developer docs: Smart charging, stack levels, and the station applying the lowest of the profiles in force
- ISO 15118-2:2014 and ISO 15118-20:2022 message schemas as the analyzer decodes them (libcbv2g), AC_EVChargeParameter, SAScheduleTuple, PMaxSchedule, EVSENotification, PaymentOption; ISO 15118-20 DisplayParameters
- ISO 15118-20:2022, scheduled and dynamic control modes, ScheduleExchange, schedule renegotiation
- IEC 61851-1:2017, PWM duty cycle and available current; Table A.6 response time
- CHARGED EVs: An ENERGY STAR charger specification program update, connected criteria, demand response through OCPP, SEP 2.0, CTA-2045A or OpenADR 2.0; rebates that require the label
- The Electric Vehicles (Smart Charge Points) Regulations 2021 (SI 2021/1467), Part 2 and Schedule 1: smart functionality, default charging hours, randomised delay, security
- GOV.UK: Regulations: electric vehicle smart charge points, in force 30 June 2022; Schedule 1 security requirements from 30 December 2022
- DESNZ: Smart Secure Electricity Systems (SSES) programme, draft load control licence regulations and conditions, consultation, December 2025; licence applications from 2026, in force from 2027
- Bundesnetzagentur: Integration von steuerbaren Verbrauchseinrichtungen (section 14a EnWG), from 1 January 2024; devices above 4.2 kW; reduction to no less than 4.2 kW
- Netze Stadtwerke Passau: making controllable consumer devices controllable under section 14a, control box behind the smart meter gateway, EEBus to the device
- e-netz Südhessen: information for installers on operating controllable consumer devices
- Brinkel, van Wijk, van Sark et al.: Enhancing smart charging in electric vehicles by addressing paused and delayed charging problems, Nature Communications, 25 June 2024
- ElaadNL / Nationale Agenda Laadinfrastructuur: Smart Charging Requirements, resuming after an indefinite pause; intermittent charging test
- ElaadNL: Results of large scale technical smart charging test of electric vehicles, 30 September 2025; 142 vehicles and 10 charge points over 11 months
- NV Energy: Residential Managed Charging Program Handbook, networked charger or telematics; 80 percent off peak